Upper Keys · MM 71–86
Islamorada
Sportfishing capital — luxury-leaning Upper-Keys market.
Islamorada is its own incorporated village across Plantation, Windley, and Upper/Lower Matecumbe Keys. Pricing-per-square-foot runs 25–40% over the Lower Keys for similar canal-front. Holiday Isle and Plantation Key are distinct submarkets.
Parcels
5,600
Median assessed value
$980,000
% in AE/VE flood zone
67%
% waterfront
49%
What to expect in Islamorada
- Village of Islamorada caps STR licenses
- Holiday Isle slip + condo combos
- Plantation Key is residential-quiet
- Sportfishing-tournament economy underpins values
Sample parcels in Islamorada
Public-records risk and insurance data on representative parcels.
Find a Islamorada realtor
We don't have a dedicated Islamorada partner yet. Submit a request and we'll match you with a vetted Keys agent within 24 hours.
How we score Islamorada
Every parcel on this site is scored against the same six-factor KeysIQ engine: flood risk, insurance cost, ROGO buildability, VR income eligibility, climate resilience, and the composite KeysIQ Score™. Read the methodology →